|
The
thing that hath been is that which shall be; and that which is done
is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the
Sun. Ecclesiastes
This
cyclical worldview of the ancients was a natural extension of the
observations of seasonal change and of decay and regeneration. It
was the dominant view in a world in which change was hard to recognize
in an individual lifetime. In such a world there is no progress.
A
philosopher of the ancient world who did see change as part of existence
was the historian Heraclitus (533-475 BC). His maxim was, You
cannot step twice into the same river; for fresh waters are ever
flowing in upon you. For him everything was becoming.
The
idea that change can bring new things into the world was not the
common point of view until the way was prepared by the acceptance
of Darwins theory of evolution. If evolution could, in time,
bring new species into being it was imaginable that the developing
processes of the world had produced new and unexpected arrangements
of all kinds.
The
first use of the word emergent to refer to phenomena
that were new and not explicable by the properties of their components
was by George Henry Lewes (1817-1878). In his book Problems of
Life and Mind (1879). Lewes contrasts the word emergent
with the word resultant and introduces the idea that
it is through emergence that novelties enter the world. He wrote
that an emergent effect is not additive, not predictable from knowledge
of its components, and not decomposable into those components.
An
early attempt to establish a philosophic interpretation of nature
as a whole with emergence as one of its guiding principles is the
work of Samuel Alexander (1859-1938). Early on he accepted and incorporated
the idea of Minkowski and Einstein that space and time were not
independent, that the only reality was space-time. In Space,
Time, and Deity (1920)he wrote:
In the course of time new complexity of motions
comes into existence, a new quality emerges, that is, a new complex
entity possesses as a matter of observed empirical fact a new or
emergent quality... Physical and chemical processes of a certain
complexity have the quality of life... The higher quality emerges
from the lower level of existence and has its roots therein, but
it emerges therefrom, and it... constitutes a new order of existence
with its special laws of behaviour
Mind is, according to our
interpretation of the facts, an emergent from life.
In
Samuel Alexanders view, there were two fundamental concepts
in the understanding of the universe. They were space-time and the
tendency of matter to move toward increasing complexity with new
qualities, or properties, emerging. This idea is at the heart of
the concept of emergence.
A
contemporary of Alexander, C. Lloyd Morgan (1852-1936), in Emergent
Evolution (1928) expanded on the idea of emergence. He saw at
each step of increasing complexity of matter new relationships forming;
new ways of acting and reacting, new properties appearing. New because
their specific nature could not be predicted before they appear
in the evidence. For an illustration he used the phase change
of water to ice. In Morgans view the lower density of ice
compared to that of water represents a new relationship among the
water molecules. As ice they are in a crystalline relationship vastly
different from their relationship to each other as liquid. The phase
change brings new emergent properties like solidity along with it.
There
is a growing consensus among scientists that high energy particle
physics and its rational, reductionism, will not reveal what we
really want to know about the universe. It given us much knowledge
but will not tell us how complexity and order emerged from the featurelessness
and chaos of the big bang. A new approach to scientific research
is in the offing. Some of its concepts include self-organization,
organizing principles, spontaneous order, nonlinear systems and,
something that as yet has no agreed name, the opposite of entropy.
Emergents
are those organizations of matter or processes that result from
the synergetic combination of simple systems into more complex ones.
Characterized by the phrase, the whole is greater than the
sum of its parts.
Emergent
properties are those novel ways of acting that come into being with
the increase in organizational complexity of systems. They are constructions
of a whole system and do not belong to the component parts of the
system. Emergent properties are collectives that can disappear when
the communicating relationship within the system is disrupted.
The
cell is an emergent from the background of inanimate matter and
brings into being the new property called life. Progress in the
world is by means of emergents and their properties.
|